Hi Taylor, you are correct, in group B factor refinement overall B factors of adjacent residues are restrained to be similar (or not too different). I will fix the documentation, thanks for pointing this out. There isn't much validation done to B factors, so dropping restraints can indeed lower R-factors but it isn't necessarily clear whether refined B factors are going to be meaningful. I guess you can try both and see what produces more meaningful B factors. Pavel On 11/25/19 16:34, Taylor Stevens wrote:
Hello,
I am currently refining a low-ish resolution structure (through the phenix.refine GUI) with phenix version 1.14 and had some questions about the use of restraints in group ADP refinement. In the phenix.refine documentation (https://www.phenix-online.org/documentation/reference/refinement.html#refine...) it is stated that “Group isotropic ADP or TLS refinement do not use any restraints”, however, this does not seem to be the case. If I look in the log file I can see the following lines of text which I believe indicate that the restraints are being applied:
|-group b-factor refinement (macro cycle = 0; iterations = 0)————————| | r_work = 0.3331 r_free = 0.3717 target = 5.823062 restraints weight = None | |——————————————————————————————————————| |-group b-factor refinement (macro cycle = 1; iterations = 22)————————| | r_work = 0.3331 r_free = 0.3717 target = 5.823062 restraints weight = 821.871| |——————————————————————————————————————| |-group b-factor refinement (macro cycle = 2; iterations = 22)————————| | r_work = 0.3331 r_free = 0.3717 target = 5.823062 restraints weight = 821.871| |——————————————————————————————————————| |-group b-factor refinement (macro cycle = 3; iterations = 22)————————| | r_work = 0.3331 r_free = 0.3717 target = 5.823062 restraints weight = 821.871| |——————————————————————————————————————|
If I manually set the wu parameter to 0 under “Refinement target weights" nothing changes, however, if I navigate to "All parameters > ADP settings > Group B-Factors" in the GUI there is a “Use restraints” box that is checked by default. If I uncheck this box, there are no longer any restraints being applied according to the log file, and in the case of the structure I am refining, there is a substantial drop in the rfree/rwork. Is this an issue with the program or documentation? Or am I misunderstanding how the program is supposed to work? Is it generally a good idea to use group ADP refinement without restraints?
Thanks,
Taylor
_______________________________________________ phenixbb mailing list [email protected] http://phenix-online.org/mailman/listinfo/phenixbb Unsubscribe: [email protected]