Dear Dr. Dias,
I tried the command line in Terminal, but Elbow still regularized the
conformation and bonds of the ligand and the result turned out to be the
same with that I ran thorough GUI. The thing is that the input pdb file has
a conformation the ligand should adopt so that I do not really want energy
minimization or geometry optimization to be done on it. Although I set
"none" for "geometry optimization" in GUI, it unfortunately changed the
ligand conformation.
Thank you,
Mengbin
On Thu, Jun 13, 2013 at 2:52 PM, Mengbin Chen
Dear Dr. Dias,
I tried the command line in Terminal, but Elbow still regularized the conformation and bonds of the ligand and the result turned out to be the same with that I ran thorough GUI. The thing is that the input pdb file has a conformation the ligand should adopt so that I do not really want energy minimization or geometry optimization to be done on it. Although I set "none" for "geometry optimization" in GUI, it unfortunately changed the ligand conformation.
Thank you, Mengbin
On Thu, Jun 13, 2013 at 2:42 PM, Joao Dias
wrote: Dear Mengbin, You can open a terminal window and run elbow as a command line.
phenix.elbow --final_geometry input_file.pdb****
Do not forget to initialize the phenix environment, depending on your terminal shell, one example is: source /Applications/PHENIX-dev-1320/Contents/phenix-dev-1320/phenix_env.sh
All the best, Joao
Dr Joao Dias****
Principal Scientist****
** **
Heptares Therapeutics Ltd****
BioPark, Broadwater Road,****
Welwyn Garden City,****
Herts, AL7 3AX****
UK
From: Mengbin Chen
Reply-To: PHENIX user mailing list Date: Thursday, 13 June 2013 19:32 To: PHENIX user mailing list Subject: [phenixbb] elbow Dear PHENIX Users,
I have been playing around with Elbow for a while, but I kept having problems generating .cif file. For "Chemical file type" and "Template PDB file", I used the pdb file of the ligand. Since the coordinates in the pdb file corresponds to a conformation desired, I chose "None" for "geometry optimization". After running Elbow, the output pdb file was completely different than the input one -- even double bonds became single bonds and 10-membered ring conformation changed. I have tried Sketcher in CCP4 package, but no good results either. Could anyone tell me how to do this correctly? Any help is appreciated!
Thank you in advance, Mengbin
-- Mengbin Chen Department of Chemistry University of Pennsylvania
[image: www.heptares.com] http://www.heptares.comhttp://www.heptares.com
The information in this e-mail is confidential and may be legally privileged. It is intended for the exclusive attention of the addressee stated above and should not be copied or disclosed to any other. If you have received this transmission in error, please make no use of its contents and contact the sender. Contact and registered office address: Heptares Therapeutics Limited, BioPark, Broadwater Road, Welwyn Garden City, Hertfordshire, AL7 3AX. Company No: 06267989
-- Mengbin Chen Department of Chemistry University of Pennsylvania
-- Mengbin Chen Department of Chemistry University of Pennsylvania
On Thu, Jun 13, 2013 at 11:53 AM, Mengbin Chen
I tried the command line in Terminal, but Elbow still regularized the conformation and bonds of the ligand and the result turned out to be the same with that I ran thorough GUI. The thing is that the input pdb file has a conformation the ligand should adopt so that I do not really want energy minimization or geometry optimization to be done on it. Although I set "none" for "geometry optimization" in GUI, it unfortunately changed the ligand conformation.
This has nothing to do with use of the GUI versus command line - the problem is that using a PDB file as the only source of chemical information is unlikely to work, especially if no hydrogens are present. At the very least you need explicit hydrogens, and ideally you need an input file that actually defines the topology, like SMILES or MOL2 or CIF. If it's a ligand that is already in the PDB you can just give it the three-letter code and it will extract this information automatically from the database included with Phenix. I guess I need to add a warning to the GUI if users try to use a PDB file alone, because this problem comes up again and again. -Nat
Hi Nat,
So I added SMILES in Chemical string, but the conformation came out to be
different than the input pdb file, even "none" was chosen for geometry
optimization.
Mengbin
On Thu, Jun 13, 2013 at 3:20 PM, Nathaniel Echols
On Thu, Jun 13, 2013 at 11:53 AM, Mengbin Chen
wrote: I tried the command line in Terminal, but Elbow still regularized the conformation and bonds of the ligand and the result turned out to be the same with that I ran thorough GUI. The thing is that the input pdb file has a conformation the ligand should adopt so that I do not really want energy minimization or geometry optimization to be done on it. Although I set "none" for "geometry optimization" in GUI, it unfortunately changed the ligand conformation.
This has nothing to do with use of the GUI versus command line - the problem is that using a PDB file as the only source of chemical information is unlikely to work, especially if no hydrogens are present. At the very least you need explicit hydrogens, and ideally you need an input file that actually defines the topology, like SMILES or MOL2 or CIF. If it's a ligand that is already in the PDB you can just give it the three-letter code and it will extract this information automatically from the database included with Phenix.
I guess I need to add a warning to the GUI if users try to use a PDB file alone, because this problem comes up again and again.
-Nat
_______________________________________________ phenixbb mailing list [email protected] http://phenix-online.org/mailman/listinfo/phenixbb
-- Mengbin Chen Department of Chemistry University of Pennsylvania
On Thu, Jun 13, 2013 at 12:50 PM, Mengbin Chen
So I added SMILES in Chemical string, but the conformation came out to be different than the input pdb file, even "none" was chosen for geometry optimization.
Could you please send us the input files off-list? This may be a bug, or it might simply be a misunderstanding about how to specify the different parameters. -Nat
participants (2)
-
Mengbin Chen
-
Nathaniel Echols