Hi all, I have seen this odd behavior with a couple of ligands in phenix 2.2.1-6174: B-factors of some well-defined ligands increase significantly during a refinement, in the range of 2-fold compared with surrounding protein residues. The density hints for full occupancy - just about as strong as for the neighboring residues. As a test, I changed the occupancy of the ligand to 0.8. Phenix refines back to 1.0. If I turn off occupancy refinement, B-factors for the ligand increase even more. While the geometry looks fine, I am left with significant positive difference density. I have refined several structures for both targets with different ligands and never ran into this. Has this been seen before and is there anything I could try? I have already tested versions 6190 and 6048 and see the same behavior. Thanks, Jan
Hi Jan, it might be helpful to provide some screen shots of the positive density you are observing. I also wonder if you have somehow introduced some model bias into your data.
All the best,John
On Friday, October 2, 2026 at 11:14:34 AM CDT, jan.abendroth--- via phenixbb
Hi Jan, have you tried to reset the B-factors? I sometimes encounter that the minimizer is trapped in a local minimum and |phenix.refine|struggles to bring them back down. You might also try Optimize ADP weights. Hope this helps! Best regards, Georg. Am 03.10.2026 um 04:32 schrieb John Bacik via phenixbb:
Hi Jan, it might be helpful to provide some screen shots of the positive density you are observing. I also wonder if you have somehow introduced some model bias into your data. All the best,John On Friday, October 2, 2026 at 11:14:34 AM CDT, jan.abendroth--- via phenixbb
wrote: Hi all, I have seen this odd behavior with a couple of ligands in phenix 2.2.1-6174:
B-factors of some well-defined ligands increase significantly during a refinement, in the range of 2-fold compared with surrounding protein residues. The density hints for full occupancy - just about as strong as for the neighboring residues. As a test, I changed the occupancy of the ligand to 0.8. Phenix refines back to 1.0. If I turn off occupancy refinement, B-factors for the ligand increase even more.
While the geometry looks fine, I am left with significant positive difference density. I have refined several structures for both targets with different ligands and never ran into this.
Has this been seen before and is there anything I could try? I have already tested versions 6190 and 6048 and see the same behavior.
Thanks, Jan _______________________________________________ phenixbb mailing list [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email [email protected] Unsubscribe: phenixbb-leave@%(host_name)s
_______________________________________________ phenixbb mailing list [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email [email protected] Unsubscribe: phenixbb-leave@%(host_name)s
participants (3)
-
Georg Mlynek -
jan.abendroth@ucb.com -
John Bacik